Dutch, French say no to Euro-nation

| | Comments (4)

Over the weekend, French voters defeated a referendum to ratify the 300-page European Constitution, and yesterday the Netherlands voted no by an even larger margin, about 62%-38%. In both countries, nearly all major political parties and civic organizations supported passage. Instapundit linked to Netherlands-based, English language blog Zacht Ei, for results and commentary. Looking back through entries before the vote, I find this one, expressing optimism that not only will the Dutch defeat the Constitution, but that the defeat means something more profound for democracy and public discourse in that country.

As far as the Netherlands are concerned: in the past few days I've often wondered what worries Dutch politicians most: that a majority is considering to vote 'no', or that the country is finally engaged in the most intense political debate since the assassination of Pim Fortuyn. Indeed, the one thing that seemed to annoy most politicians about Fortuyn is that they suddenly had to debate issues which a large part of the electorate had wanted to address for years, and thanks to Fortuyn, they no longer could avoid it (though Ad Melkert famously tried).

I've felt strangely hopeful for the past few weeks, as the voice of dissent gradually increased in strength, that the tide may indeed be turning, and that this is the first step towards a better way of governing, in which politicians rule on behalf of the people rather than over them from a pedestal of feigned moral superiority.

My understanding of Dutch politics is limited, but it's my understanding that two or three parties have dominated -- trading places in the cabinet but operating under an unquestioned consensus. You get to an unstable political situation when no dominant party addresses an issue that matters to a large percentage of the population. In the Netherlands, immigration (particularly Muslim immigration) and European integration are two issues that had been ignored by the traditionally dominant parties.

The Netherlands sounds a lot like Tulsa: a powerful political elite confronted by upstart voices challenging the conventional wisdom, and a growing sense among the public that politicians should make government work for all the people, not just a favored few.

4 Comments

MikeH said:

I think it goes further than Tulsa about a government catering to the elite. Tulsa is just a microcosm.

During Clinton's term and the national debate over NAFTA, I never saw one national poll that favored the trade agreement. I venture to say that had there been an election on the treaty, it would have taken a lot more propaganda to sway voters than was already used. Looking at the trade deficit since then, the massive amount of corporate welfare, and executive compensation, would do nothing to persuade people otherwise today. It takes a gutsy politician, like Sen. Coburn, to question such favoritism. But it's those same gutsy politicians that are often easily maligned by the powerful elite.

W. said:

MikeH, you had me until you mentioned Sen. Coburn. Couldn't you have up with someone else, one who at least doesn't habitually contract diarrhea of the mouth? He even ticked off his fellow Oklahoma senator last week.

MikeH said:

I certainly don't mean to imply that Coburn is a model senator, but I'll argue with anybody that he does have guts!

Hugh_Drew said:

Not sure that Tulsa is like the Netherlands.

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Michael Bates published on June 2, 2005 12:15 AM.

TfEI reaction to Supreme Court recall decision was the previous entry in this blog.

Anglican Books of Homilies is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Contact

Feeds

Subscribe to feed Subscribe to this blog's feed:
Atom
RSS
[What is this?]

Support BatesLine

Show your appreciation and help fund hosting and research expenses:

Official PayPal Seal

Enjoy affordable and reliable hosting with Bluehost and support BatesLine at the same time -- click here!