A guide to Tulsa & Pawnee County Judicial Elections, 2026

This is an update of an entry from 16 years ago. The structure and offices are the same, but the names are different for 2026.

It took me a while to puzzle all this out, and I thought others might be interested as well.

Oklahoma has 26 District Courts. Tulsa County and Pawnee County constitute Judicial District No. 14. State law says that District 14 has 14 district judge offices. (Why are Tulsa County and Pawnee County coupled together? Why not Pawnee with, say, Osage, and Tulsa on its own, as Oklahoma County is? Why doesn't the Judicial District line up with the District Attorney District?)

One judge must reside in and be nominated from Pawnee County, eight must reside in and be nominated from Tulsa County. If there are more than two candidates for any of those nine offices, there is a non-partisan nominating primary in the appropriate county, and the top two vote-getters are on the general election ballot. (Even if one gets more than 50% of the vote, the top two still advance.)

In the general election, all voters in Pawnee and Tulsa Counties vote on those nine seats.

The remaining five district judges are selected by electoral division in Tulsa County. In order to comply with the Voting Rights Act, Tulsa County is divided into five electoral divisions, one of which (Electoral Division 3) has a "minority-majority" population. (The minority-majority district is much smaller than the other four, as it must be in order to guarantee that the electorate is majority African-American.) For each of these five offices, if there are three or more candidates, there is a non-partisan nominating primary. If one candidate gets more than 50% of the vote, he is elected; otherwise, the top two advance to the general election. For each of these five offices, the candidates must reside in the corresponding electoral division, and only voters in that electoral division will vote for that office in the primary and general election. (Oklahoma County, Judicial District No. 7, is the only other county with judges elected by division.)

Despite the three different paths one can take to be elected, a Judge in Judicial District No. 14 can be assigned to try any case within the two counties.

Each county in the state also elects an Associate District Judge, nominated and elected countywide. Incumbent Tulsa County Associate District Judge Todd Chesbro has been re-elected without opposition. Pawnee County Associate District Judge Patrick Pickerill was re-elected without opposition.

In addition to the elected judges, the District has a certain number of Special Judges, who are appointed by and serve at the pleasure of the District Judges.

All this I was able to puzzle out from prior knowledge and browsing through the relevant sections of the Oklahoma Statutes. What I still couldn't quite figure out is which of the 14 offices corresponded with the five electoral divisions, and which one was nominated from Pawnee County. Although electoral division 4 votes for office 4, I was pretty sure the pattern did not apply to the other offices. Back in 2006, after a few phone calls, someone from the Tulsa County Election Board found the relevant info in the League of Women Voters handbook.

So here it is, for your reference and mine, with the party registration of each judge noted in parentheses. (Yes, I know Oklahoma judicial races are non-partisan and judicial candidates are supposed to refrain from mentioning party affiliation, but I'm not subject to that restriction, and party registration is a matter of public record. Party affiliation may be some indication of a candidate's judicial philosophy. Judges now have the option to have their voter registration "unlisted" for their personal security, and many have availed themselves of that option; I have question marks for those judges, which I will replace with better information if it becomes available.)

Offices elected by Tulsa County Electoral Divisions in red.
Offices nominated by Pawnee County in blue.

¹ Not seeking re-election.
² Appointed by Gov. Stitt to fill unexpired term of Jim Huber, who was appointed to the Court of Civil Appeals.

Although all 14 offices are up for election this year, only three offices are contested, and only one of those will be on the primary ballot.

Two incumbent judges have drawn opponents: Caroline Wall in Office 1 and Kevin Gray in Office 12. Wall is a registered Republican, being challenged by Tom Sawyer, a rematch of their 2018 contest. Gray is being challenged by Christopher Camp, also a registered Republican.

One of the two open seats, Office 4, currently held by Daman Cantrell (I), has drawn three candidates, Special Judge Loretta Radford, former prosecutor Dustin Allen, and Rogers County Assistant District Attorney Phillip Peak. This is the only one of the five offices elected by electoral division that is being contested this year. If any one candidate gets 50% or more of the primary vote, that candidate is elected, and there will not be a runoff in November.

The other open seat, Office 11, is currently held by Rebecca Brett Nightingale. Special Judge April Siebert was the only candidate to file for the seat, so she has been elected.

Judicial Election District 4 voters will be the only ones to have a judicial race on the ballot on June 16, 2026. In rough terms, the district includes all of Tulsa County north of 66th Street North (including Sperry, Skiatook, Collinsville, Owasso), nearly all of the the City of Tulsa in Tulsa County east of Memorial Drive and north of 61st Street.

The best way to know which electoral division you live in is to consult the Tulsa County judicial electoral division map. Click here for the full collection of Tulsa County district and precinct maps.