Child abuse prosecutor backs Kunzweiler, chides McCarty for lies

| | TrackBacks (0)

Amy Dickens is a prosecutor now, working in the Crimes Against Children unit, but many years ago she was our kids' babysitter and part of our church family. Dickens received the Pillar of Hope award last fall from the Child Advocacy Network for her work prosecuting cases involving child abuse. She has some words about tomorrow's election for Tulsa County District Attorney that are worth your attention.

Tomorrow is the day to vote for Steve Kunzweiler to remain the Tulsa County DA.

Colleen McCarty has lied about a lot of things during her campaign but one particular lie so offends me, both personally and professionally, that I feel I have to address it.

Anyone who claims that our office does not prosecute cases involving sexual abuse of children under age 12 is LYING. I've spent seven years prosecuting those crimes.

Someone who has never tried a single case may have the naive luxury of believing that, to quote her directly, "you would be hard pressed to find 12 people in Tulsa county who would NOT convict a child molester and sentence them to 25 years." If only that were true.

The reality is this: IT IS HARD to secure convictions in those cases. It is hard to watch attorneys deliberately confuse small children, twist their words, make them cry, then tell a jury the reason they "can't keep their story straight" is that they are lying. It is hard to explain to a jury why so many times children don't disclose right away, or how frustratingly quickly DNA evidence disappears. It is hard to get jurors to understand that someone who abuses a child for a period of months deserves that 25 year minimum just as much as someone who abuses a child for a period of years. And it is hard to get jurors to tune out the little but loud "reform groups" who work tirelessly to shift society's focus to criminals who want to paint themselves as victims rather than keeping the focus on the actual victims - groups like those McCarty has spent her entire career working for, advocating for criminals.

That doesn't mean we don't file those cases. We do. And we secure convictions in a lot of them because experienced prosecutors handle them. But anyone who thinks that prosecutors can just snap our fingers and get a jury to convict every single time because we say so is frighteningly naive. It simply does not work that way, which McCarty doesn't understand because she's never actually done this job. And claiming that we do not prosecute those cases because the 25 year minimum makes them too hard is an outright lie.

When you're a prosecutor you don't get to lie. You don't get to spin, or twist people's words, or provide incomplete context, or actively work to deceive people to get them on your side. Every single thing Colleen McCarty is doing in her campaign is the very opposite of what it means to be a prosecutor.

On June 16th vote Steve Kunzweiler for DA.

Well said, Amy. Steve Kunzweiler has put together and kept together a great team at the Tulsa County DA's office, despite budget restrictions and the heartbreak of working with victims. Amy is one of several ADAs that our family got to know before their time working at the DAs office, so we have a good sense of the kind of dedicated, hardworking, and intelligent attorneys that Kunzweiler has recruited and retained. None of the attorneys I know want to see Kunzweiler replaced.

(Dickens mentioned separately that, although the legislature recently reduced the minimum sentence from 25 to 10 years, crimes that were committed prior to the change must still be tried under the previous sentencing minimums.)

Kunzweiler-DA.png

Here are a few of my thoughts as we reach the end of this campaign:

In the fight against crime, Colleen McCarty has spent her entire almost-six-year-long legal career in the ringside seats, criticizing those in the arena for being too harsh and punitive against the bad guys. McCarty could have joined many of her law-school classmates and gotten hired as an Assistant District Attorney, learning what it is to try a case before a jury, learning about the legal obstacles that get in the way of holding criminals to account. Instead, McCarty led progressive non-profits, funded by progressive foundations like GKFF, working for leniency for criminals, working to place obstacles in the way of prosecutors. While Amy Dickens was working to put child abusers in prison, Colleen McCarty was suing the State Department of Education to force public schools to play gender-pretend with pronouns, complaining that "Walters and the State Board have repeatedly denied the existence of transgender students, insisting their genders are merely a fabrication of the 'woke left.'" They are, Colleen.

McCarty is a classic case of the Dunning-Kruger Effect. She believes she can be a great DA because she has no idea what's involved in being a DA. She's never tried a case before a jury. She doesn't know what she doesn't know. She had a total of three months at two different DA offices as an intern in law school. McCarty can be very persuasive, but only in controlled conditions where there isn't anyone else present to cross-examine or rebut her claims. If she's elected, maybe McCarty can ask the judges to keep defense counsel and their evidence out of the courtroom as a special accommodation for her "disability." The recent Rotary Club candidate forum displays the stark contrast between someone who knows the job and is doing it well, and someone who can only criticize out of ignorance.

0 TrackBacks

Listed below are links to blogs that reference this entry: Child abuse prosecutor backs Kunzweiler, chides McCarty for lies.

TrackBack URL for this entry: https://www.batesline.com/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/9488

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Michael Bates published on June 15, 2026 12:29 PM.

Why Mazzei? was the previous entry in this blog.

Who's behind Oklahoma Grassroots Conservatives LLC? is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.

Contact

Feeds

Subscribe to feed Subscribe to this blog's feed:
Atom
RSS
[What is this?]